Which U.S. Counties Gained and Lost Jobs Since the Pandemic

The U.S. financial system has added some 19 million jobs prior to now 4 years — all the roles misplaced within the pandemic plus hundreds of thousands extra. The comeback has been quicker and extra full than any in latest a long time, or perhaps ever.

Nevertheless it has additionally been uneven.

In some elements of the nation, jobs got here again rapidly as soon as vaccines have been obtainable, if not earlier. In a lot of these locations, extra individuals are working, and incomes more cash, than ever earlier than.

In different places, the rebound has been a lot slower. As of 2023, greater than two in 5 U.S. counties — 43 % — nonetheless hadn’t regained all the roles they misplaced within the early months of the pandemic, based on annual knowledge from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. A few of these locations have been struggling lengthy earlier than 2020. Others had been thriving economically and have been knocked astray by an airborne shock few noticed coming.

The geography of that unequal restoration helps reveal how the pandemic — and the insurance policies adopted in response to it — reshaped the U.S. financial system, altering the sort of work Individuals do and the place they do it.

The patterns may have electoral implications: The battleground states that may assist resolve November’s presidential election embrace a few of the largest winners within the restoration — but additionally a number of of the losers.

The winners have some issues in frequent. They’re concentrated within the South and the Mountain West, notably in suburban counties, which have performed properly in an period of distant and hybrid work.

They are typically locations the place job losses have been comparatively delicate within the first place, actually because their main employers have been in industries that have been much less affected by — or that even benefited from — the disruptions of the pandemic. They’re, on common, richer and higher educated than counties which were slower to rebound. They voted disproportionately for Donald J. Trump within the 2020 presidential election.

The losers, in contrast, are typically concentrated each in large cities, which have been hit notably laborious by the pandemic, and in rural areas, which have been struggling lengthy earlier than the virus struck. They’re comparatively poor, on common, however with notable exceptions: San Francisco and a number of other of its rich neighbors, for instance, have but to regain all the roles they misplaced within the pandemic.

The pandemic additionally modified the forms of jobs that Individuals maintain. Eating places, accommodations, film theaters and different in-person companies laid off hundreds of thousands of staff, whereas warehouses and trucking firms went on a hiring spree to satisfy the surge in demand.

These shifts have reversed, however regularly and incompletely: America has extra truck drivers and fewer waiters, as a share of the work power, than it did in 2019.

The financial modifications that began within the early days of the pandemic have performed out in a different way in several elements of the nation — together with the states probably to resolve the election. Nevada, which relies upon extra closely on tourism jobs than some other state, was hit particularly laborious within the pandemic, and whereas Las Vegas is booming once more, not all the roles have returned. That will assist clarify why each main presidential candidates have sought to woo on line casino staff there by promising to eradicate taxes on their ideas.

Hospitality jobs have additionally been slower to return within the Northern swing states like Michigan and Pennsylvania than in Solar Belt states like Georgia and Arizona, the place pandemic restrictions have been lifted earlier.

Authorities insurance policies have additionally helped form the rebound within the job market. Large federal investments in infrastructure, inexperienced power and high-tech manufacturing below President Biden helped gasoline fast hiring in manufacturing and heavy development.

In Nevada, new manufacturing facility jobs — and jobs constructing these factories — helped offset the sluggish rebound in tourism. Arizona has loved one of many largest development booms of any state thanks partly to large new chip manufacturing vegetation whose funding contains federal grants.

Partly due to these patterns, battleground states within the Solar Belt have thrived lately, at the very least in job development. Maricopa County, Ariz., which incorporates Phoenix and is the positioning of the chip vegetation, is without doubt one of the fastest-growing large counties (these with at the very least a million residents) by way of employment. Jackson County, Ga., is without doubt one of the quickest rising of any dimension — up greater than 60 % since 2019, partly due to a serious new plant that manufactures batteries for electrical autos.

That fast development has introduced alternatives, but additionally challenges, notably a important scarcity of reasonably priced housing. It’s no coincidence that the presidential campaigns of Mr. Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris have put housing on the middle of their financial messages.

The Northern “Blue Wall” states face a unique set of challenges. They struggled economically earlier than the pandemic and have been laggards within the restoration.

Pennsylvania, for instance, largely missed out on the development and manufacturing booms. Allegheny County, which incorporates Pittsburgh, is the one large county within the nation the place whole employment has fallen greater than 5 % since 2019. However the losses have been widespread: Of the state’s 67 counties, 51 misplaced jobs from 2019 to 2023.

How, precisely, these traits will play out on Election Day is unclear. Polls present that voters are apprehensive in regards to the financial system throughout the nation, not simply within the locations the place the restoration has been weakest. That could be as a result of, at the very least till just lately, many Individuals have been apprehensive much less about discovering a job than in regards to the rising price of residing.

That may very well be altering now, as rising unemployment and slowing job development have begun to reveal cracks within the labor market’s basis. That’s very true in states like Pennsylvania, the place hiring has lagged, however even fast-growing states have areas the place the labor market is struggling.

Whereas the election will in all probability be determined by voters in a handful of battleground states, practically each place seems totally different than it did 4 years in the past.

In Lee County, Fla., a wave of development helped offset a giant decline in resort and restaurant jobs. Portsmouth, Va., bucked the nationwide pattern and added hospitality jobs due largely to the opening of the state’s first everlasting on line casino. McLean County, Unwell., has gained 1000’s of producing jobs lately, a lot of them on the electrical car maker Rivian.

See what has modified in your county: